IBM Project Debater: Artificial intelligence participates in historic debate with human 402m2c

bruno martinez avatar
IBM's artificial intelligence platform faced Harish Nataranja, record holder of victories in debates on an unprecedented topic

What skills will remain human in the future? If it depends on the artificial intelligence of the IBM, the list will only decrease. At the IBM Think 2019, the company held a debate session between its artificial intelligence, IBM Project Debate, and Harish Nataranja, debate expert and winner of the 2016 World Debate Championship. 6d3y1m

IBM's artificial intelligence is already debating more than many people 5c2x3e

Ibm project debate: was going to debate with a human expert in contest
Debate took place in a normal way, as if the AI ​​were a human

IBM puts your project above existing virtual assistants. Even in this post.

To test its efficiency, this Monday (11) the system faced Harish Nataranja, first place in the 2016 World Debate Championship and collector of several other titles in the category. The discussion was presented and mediated by John Donvan, presenter of the American network ABC. The two participants learned about the theme only on stage: "should we subsidize preschools".

Harish natarajan alongside artificial intelligence called debate
Harish Natarajan alongside artificial intelligence called Debate

O IBM Project Debate stood as a defense nataranja stood in opposition. Each had just minutes to study and prepare arguments. Both initially featured a four-minute opening, four-minute rebuttal, and two-minute final summary.

nataranja was the most qualified opponent with whom the AI ​​of IBM already talked. THE IBM considered the event more than a testament to his AI's capabilities, but also a way to expand his abilities.

Both parties gathered information in a clear and concise way, presenting solid and correlated arguments, without it being possible to detect flaws in what was stated. This was expected from Harish, the record holder for the most victories in debates. However, it is impressive to note the potential and evolution of artificial intelligence in IBM on a topic it was never prepared to address.

O IBM Project Debate behaved very similarly to a human, with consistency in his argument, without making mistakes or contradicting himself.

The debate was watched by more than 100 journalists and was broadcast live around the world. Viewers could vote for the best debater via the link ibm.co/vote. O Project Debater he lost that contest, but he didn't disappoint, given his good performance, unheard of against such a qualified opponent.

Ibm project debate: was going to debate with a human expert in contest
Natarajan managed to convince 17% of the public to change their position, contrary to that of Debater

the operation of the machine 416i6x

In order to achieve such resourcefulness, the Project Debater you have the infinite library of the internet on your side. AI knowledge consists of about 10 billion sentences, taken from news and newspapers. At the time of a debate without prior preparation, the system searches for small excerpts from useful sources, correlating the facts with the debate proposal and its favorable or unfavorable position to it.

Ibm project debate: was going to debate with a human expert in contest
IBM had its biggest practical test held this Monday (11)

With the ability to understand deep human language and its infinite nuances, AI seeks to harvest the clearest and most accurate interpretations. then the debate need to build the strongest and most diverse arguments, without the possibility of contradiction or redundancy.

While natarajan spoke, the Project Debater listened and analyzed the arguments used. The AI ​​is able to think of new arguments in the reder, in addition to predicting the opponent's next lines.

How useful is IBM Project Debate? 5d64b

For IBM, are several. Artificial intelligence can stimulate healthy debate in online forums, prepare lawyers for trials, advise entrepreneurs, serve clients or improve critical thinking in young people.

In fact, it is already accessible on the internet.. O IBM Project Debate can be accessed through this site, where it is possible to contribute by teaching artificial intelligence to better discuss certain controversial topics, such as the banning of violent games for minors ou the harm of online shopping.

The intention is to open discussion topics where Internet s send their arguments (against or in favor) of the topic and the algorithm collects the arguments to build a text with three strengths for the discussion. The author traveled to San Francisco on IBM's invitation to IBM Think 2019.

What use would you make of a debating robot? Comment below!

Source: IBM Research Blog

Leave a comment Cancel reply 26673o
Related Posts 593ri

Xbox Games Showcase 2025: See the event's main releases 6p25u

With plenty of new announcements, the Xbox Games Showcase showcased several new games, including Call of Duty Black Ops 7, Silksong, and the ROG Xbox Ally handheld console. Check out everything that happened!
Tiago Rodrigues Avatar
Learn more

Summer Game Fest 2025: Check out everything that happened at the event 5f6l2k

Summer Game Fest 2025 is here and we finally had the announcement of Resident Evil 9 (Resident Evil Requiem), a new game from RGG Studio and much more. Check it out
Tiago Rodrigues Avatar
Learn more

See everything announced for PS5 in June's State of Play 6b5y44

The event brought news about the new 007 game, a teaser for Ghost of Yotei and a new fighting game from Arc System Works. Check out all the announcements
Tiago Rodrigues Avatar
Learn more